10 colour contrast checking tools to improve the accessibility of your design
In case you're wondering why I care (and why I think you should care) about the colour contrast of a website, it's very simple. If text does not have sufficient contrast compared to its background, people will have problems. People with colour blindness or other visual impairments as well as people browsing the Web under less than ideal circumstances (bad monitor, window reflections, sunlight hitting the screen) may not be able to read the text, at least not without difficulty.
And you don't really want that, do you? If you publish text on a website, as most people do, I'm guessing that in almost all cases it is because you want people to read that text. So colour contrast, whether you think about it or not, is important to you, your clients, and your end users.
I've become so accustomed to checking the contrast of any designs I create or implement that I sort of take it for granted that everybody does. Apparently this is not the case, so I figured it would be nice to be able to refer people to a list of various tools that help you check colour contrast. Hence this article.
A very brief explanation of how colour contrast ratios are calculated is in order. There are different algorithms used to calculate contrast ratios. Some tools use the luminosity contrast ratio algorithm mentioned by the WCAG (Web Content Accessibility Guidelines) 2.0 working draft, while others use the colour brightness and colour difference algorithms that are mentioned in a companion document to WCAG 1.0. Some even use both.
Note that neither of these algorithms are W3C recommendations (at least not yet), but they are still useful for determining if a combination of text and background colours is likely to cause problems for people with colour blindness or other visual impairments.
With that background out of the way, on to the actual colour contrast checking tools. Some tools are Web based, while others are standalone applications or browser extensions that you run locally on your computer.
- Colour Contrast Check: The first really intuitive online tool for checking colours that I know of, Jonathan Snook's Colour Contrast Check lets you input foreground and background colours either by entiering hexadecimal values or by adjusting sliders. The tool gives you immediate feedback by showing what the chosen colour combination looks like and whether it passes the test.
- Colour Contrast Analyser: Gez Lemon's Colour Contrast Analyser uses the same algorithm as the Colour Contrast Check tool, so the results should be identical. The difference is that this tool has no live feedback and no sliders, meaning that you will need to enter the values for foreground and background colours into a form and submit it, after which the results are displayed.
- Colour Contrast Visualiser: Using a slightly different approach, Tom Hooper's Colour Contrast Visualiser helps you find acceptable colour combinations by visualising the colours that provide sufficient contrast on a colour palette. Colour Contrast Visualiser is available in Flash and Adobe AIR versions, so you will need support for either of those to use it.
- Colour Contrast Analyser Firefox Extension: Instead of having you enter each colour combination manually, Gez Lemon's Firefox extension finds all text elements in a document and examines the difference between foreground and background colours for them. It displays the results in a new tab, complete with previews of the colours. This can look a bit overwhelming, but it's a good way of finding problematic areas of a design. Obviously this tool does not work with images – you'll need an HTML document for it to work.
- CSS Analyser: Another tool created by Gez Lemon, the CSS Analyser does a colour contrast test of your CSS. It also validates the CSS and checks that relevant text sizes are specified in a relative unit of measurement.
- Luminosity Contrast Ratio Analyser: This tool, also created by Gez Lemon, tests foreground and background colour combinations according to an algorithm developed by the Trace R&D Center.
- Vischeck: A colour blindness simulator that can be used online or as a Photoshop plugin that appears in the "Filter" menu. The online tool simulates colour blindness on an image that you upload or on a web page that you specify, while the Photoshop plugin changes the colours of the document you are working on.
- Contrast Analyser, Version 2.0: A standalone application available for Windows and Mac OS X. This is a very neat application that does pretty much everything except analyse a web page for you. You can specify the foreground and background colours numerically or by pulling sliders, you can set it to use the colour/brightness or luminosity algorithms, and it will check and preview the selected colours against various types of colour blindness.
- Graybit: An online tool developed by Jona Fenocchi and Mike Cherim. This tool does what you can guess from its name – it lets you submit a URL to a web page which will be converted to grayscale and displayed in your web browser.
- Sim Daltonism: Available for Mac OS X only, this standalone application does not calculate colour contrast, but is still very useful. It simulates various kinds of colour blindness in realtime, which makes it easy to check if a design is likely to cause problems.
Try them, find your favourite, and use it
All tools mentioned here are free, so try them all to find the ones that suit your setup and workflow best. I don't think it makes a lot of difference which tools you use, as long as you do use one that calculates the contrast ratio and one that simulates colour blindness.
The colour blindness simulation tools really help you understand how difficult it can be for a person with colour blindness to distinguish links that only differ in colour from the surrounding text.
Finally, I don't think the results of these tools (or rather the algorithms they use) need to be followed slavishly. Large headings and text that is of minor importance don't necessarily have to pass, while any text that is essential to the site (like the body copy) really should.
Use the results as guidance, apply some of your own common sense, and you should be able to find a balance between sufficient contrast and pleasing aesthetics.
Update: I have been informed by Steve Faulkner that the Colour Contrast Analyser for Web Pages provides the same functionality as Contrast Analyser, Version 2.0 but uses an outdated algorithm. I removed it from the list and replaced it with Graybit.
Sorry for any confusion that may have caused.
This article has been translated into the following languages:
- Belorussian: 10 прылад праверкі кантрасту вашага дызайну для паляпшэння яго чытальнасці (Translation by PC)
- Russian: 10 инструментов проверки контраста вашего дизайна для улучшения его „читабельности“ (Translation by Alexey Bass)